| Year | Result Score and Venue |
| 1905 | RNB Portsmouth bt Cambridge 2-1 AET at Plymouth |
| 1906 | RNB Portsmouth bt RNB Chatham 2-0 at Fratton park (Replay after 3-3 at Pitt street Portsmouth) |
| 1907 | RNB Chatham bt HMS Excellent 2-0 at Chatham |
| 1908 | RNB Devonport bt HMS Excellent 1-0 at Portsmouth (Replay after 1-1 draw) |
| 1909 | RNB Devonport bt HMS Achilles 1-0 at Chatham (Replay after drawn first game) |
| 1910 | RNB Portsmouth bt RNB Shotley 2-0 at Fratton park |
| 1911 | Gunnery School Devonport bt RNB Portsmouth 2-1 at Devonport |
| 1912 | RNB Devonport bt HMS Excellent 2-1 at Portsmouth |
| 1913 | RNB Chatham bt RNB Devonport 3-0 at Portsmouth |
| 1914 | RNB Chatham bt RNB Devonport 2-0 at Portsmouth (Replay after drawn first game) |
| 1915 to 1919 No games played due to World War 1 |
| 1920 | RMLI Chatham bt RNB Devonport 3-0 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1921 | HMS Dolphin bt HMS Hecla 3-0 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1922 | RMA Eastney bt RMLI Plymouth 2-0 at Pitt Street Portsmouth |
| 1923 | RMLI Chatham 4 (CSgt Hibben 4) HMS Vernon 0 at Fratton park Portsmouth on 11th April 1923 |
| 1924 | HMS Excellent bt RNB Chatham 2-1 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1925 | HMS Excellent bt Battle Sqn Atlantic Fleet 4-0 at Devonport |
| 1926 | RNB Devonport bt RMB Chatham 2-1 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1927 | RNB Devonport bt Battle Cruiser Sqn Atlantic Fleet 4-0 Devonport |
| 1928 | HMS Excellent bt RNB Chatham 3-2 at Fratton Park Portsmouth |
| 1929 | RNB Devonport bt RNB Portsmouth 5-3 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1930 | RNB Chatham bt HMS Excellent 5-0 at Gillingham |
| 1931 | RM Chatham bt RNB Devonport 3-1 at Gillingham |
| 1932 | 2nd Battle Sqn Home Fleet bt RM Plymouth 1-0 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1933 | Depot RM Deal bt RNB Devonport 3-0 Venue Not Known |
| 1934 | RNB Chatham bt HMS Excellent 2-1 at Portsmouth |
| 1935 | HMS Excellent bt RM Plymouth 2-0 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1936 | HMS Drake bt HMS Pembroke 3-1 at Devonport |
| 1937 | HMS Excellent bt HMS Drake 5-1 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1938 | HMS Victory bt HMS Pembroke 3-1 at RM Chatham |
| 1939 | HMS Ark Royal bt RNB Portsmouth 2-0 at Pitt Street Portsmouth |
| 1940 to 1946 No games played due to World War 2 |
| 1947 | RM Portsmouth bt RM Chatham 2-1 AET at Fratton Park Portsmouth 10th May 1947 |
| 1948 | RM Chatham bt RNB Lee 1-0 Chatham |
| 1949 | RM Portsmouth bt RM Chatham 3-1 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1950 | HMS Daedalus bt RNB Devonport 4-1 at Home park Plymouth |
| 1951 | HMS Mercury bt Reserve Fleet Chatham 5-2 at Fratton Park Portsmouth |
| 1952 | RNB Devonport bt RM Depot Deal score & venue not known |
| 1953 | HMS Daedalus bt RM Depot Deal 6-3 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1954 | HMS Diskin bt HMS Victory 2-1 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1955 | RNAS Culdrose bt PRORM 2-1 venue not known |
| 1956 | HMS Collingwood bt HMS Daedalus 2-1 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1957 | RM Portsmouth bt RM Chatham 4-2 at Fratton park Portsmouth |
| 1958 | RNAS Ford bt RMB Chatham 4-2 AET at United Services No1 pitch Portsmouth |
| 1959 | HMS Daedalus bt HMS Collingwood 2-1 at Gosport |
| 1960 | HMS Victory bt HMS Seahawk 4-3 venue not known |
| 1961 | HMS Ariel bt HMS Ganges 5-2 AET venue not known |
| 1962 | ITCRM bt HMS Vernon 4-2 AET on the 14th Dec 1961 at United Services Portsmouth. ITCRM scorers were Mne Rooke, Jones, Mne Quinn, Mne Holly. |
| 1963 | RNAS Culdrose bt RNAS Lossiemouth 2-1 at Lossiemouth |
| 1964 | HMS Collingwood bt HMS Maidstone 1-0 at Rosyth |
| 1965 | HMS Collingwood bt RM Deal 2-0 at Portsmouth |
| 1966 | HMS Excellent bt ITCRM 1-0 at Portsmouth |
| 1967 | 41Cdo RM bt HMS Dolphin 3-1 at Plymouth |
| 1968 | HMS Collingwood bt HMS Hampshire 2-1 AET at Portsmouth |
| 1969 | HMS Lochinvar bt HMS Bulwark 3-1 at Rosyth |
| 1970 | HMS Daedalus bt HMS Condor 2-1 at Arbroath |
| 1971 | HMS Daedalus bt HMS Collingwood 1-0 at Portsmouth |
| 1972 | HMS Daedalus bt HQ 3rd Cdo Bde 1-0 at Plymouth |
| 1973 | HMS Osprey bt HMS Heron 3-2 at Weymouth |
| 1974 | HMS Heron bt HMS Blake 2-0 at Weymouth |
| 1975 | RNAS Culdrose bt HMS Pembroke 3-2 at Portsmouth |
| 1976 | HMS Collingwood bt RM Poole 3-1 at Portsmouth |
| 1977 | RNAS Culdrose bt Depot RM Deal 2-1 at Deal |
| 1978 | HMS Collingwood bt HMS Sultan 5-0 at Gosport |
| 1979 | HMS Heron bt HMS Intrepid 2-0 at Yeovilton |
| 1980 | HMS Heron bt HMY Brittannia 1-0 at Yeovilton |
| 1981 | HMS Nelson bt CTCRM 2-1 AET at Lympstone |
| 1982 | HMS Heron bt HMS Cochrane 1-0 at Yeovilton |
| 1983 | HMS Heron bt HMS Pembroke 5-0 at Chatham |
| 1984 | HMS Neptune bt CTCRM 3-2 at HMS Temeraire |
| 1985 | CTCRM bt HMS Nelson 2-1 at HMS Temeraire |
| 1986 | CTCRM bt HMS Cochrane 3-2 at CTCRM (Mne Kay,Sgt Dixon,Sgt D Sharp) |
| 1987 | CTCRM bt HMS Sultan 4-1 at Gosport |
| 1988 | HMS Sultan bt RNAS Culdrose 1-0 at Culdrose |
| 1989 | HMS Sultan bt CTCRM 4-3 at Portsmouth |
| 1990 | CTCRM bt HMS Neptune 3-2 at CTCRM |
| 1991 | HMS Thunderer score & opposition not known |
| 1992 | HMS Seahawk bt HMS Neptune 3-2 at RNAS Culdrose |
| 1993 | HMS Nelson won score & opposition not known |
| 1994 | HMS Neptune bt CTCRM 3-2 AET at Rosyth |
| 1995 | HMS Daedalus bt CTCRM 2-1 at Lympstone |
| 1996 | HMS Neptune bt HMS Excellent 4-1 at Vale of Leven |
| 1997 | HMS Sultan bt HMS Seahawk 4-3 at RNAS Culdrose |
| 1998 | HMS Seahawk bt HMS Dryad 4-2 at HMS Temeraire |
| 1999 | HMS Seahawk bt HMS Collingwood 5-0 at HMS Drake |
| 2000 | CTCRM bt HMS Drake 1-0 at HMS Drake |
| 2001 | HMS Seahawk bt HMS Neptune 4-1 at HMS Temeraire |
| 2002 | 42Cdo bt HMS Drake 4-2 at HMS Drake |
| 2003 | HMS Sultan bt HMS Collingwood 3-2 at HMS Temeraire |
| 2004 | CTCRM bt HMS Neptune 1-0 at HMS Temeraire |
| 2005 | CTCRM bt HMS Heron 3-0 at HMS Temeraire |
| 2006 | CTCRM bt HMS Heron 1-0 at HMS Temeraire |
| 2007 | HMS Heron bt FPGRM 3-2 on Pens after 0-0 FT & 1-1 AET at HMS Temeraire |
| 2008 | 45Cdo RM bt HMS Heron 1-0 (Mne Ian Danby MC) at HMS Temeraire |
| 2009 | FPGRM bt HMS Seahawk 3-0 (Mne's Hill,Hebditch & Connett) at HMS Temeraire |